[CP2K-user] [CP2K:22456] Suggestion: Improving Spin-Polarized SCF Convergence for Doublet Systems in CP2K

Zhen Wu nangoaaaa at gmail.com
Thu Nov 5 06:53:31 UTC 2026



Dear CP2K Developers,

I would like to suggest improving CP2K's treatment of spin-polarized 
calculations for doublet systems, particularly for surface adsorption 
models such as OH adsorbed on ZnO.

For systems with a relatively small band gap under the PBE functional, I 
have encountered serious convergence and consistency issues when performing 
spin-polarized calculations for OH-adsorbed ZnO surfaces.

   1. 
   
   *Using the OT method:* When I apply the standard OT settings that work 
   well for bulk ZnO, the calculation can produce a normal band gap in the 
   α-spin channel, while the β-spin channel becomes metallic. In some cases, 
   the calculated β-spin LUMO–HOMO gap even becomes negative.
   2. 
   
   *Using the diagonalization method:* I have tried different SCF mixing 
   schemes, but none of them can achieve convergence for these doublet 
   spin-polarized systems. Eventually, I can only obtain SCF convergence by 
   enabling smearing.
   
Beyond the additional computational cost, this creates a serious problem 
for maintaining consistent computational settings across surface adsorption 
models. Many of my previously calculated surface structures may need to be 
recalculated simply because the same calculation settings cannot be applied 
consistently.

There is also a further problem when I attempt to use the converged PBE 
results as initial wavefunctions for subsequent hybrid-functional 
calculations:

   1. 
   
   *Hybrid functional + ADMM + OT:* Because the number of virtual orbitals 
   is inconsistent, the PBE wavefunction obtained with smearing cannot be 
   directly used as the initial guess for this calculation.
   2. 
   
   *Hybrid functional + ADMM + diagonalization:* Keeping the same number of 
   virtual orbitals as in the PBE calculation allows the calculation to run. 
   However, the original problem remains: the SCF mixing schemes still fail to 
   converge for the doublet spin-polarized system.
   3. 
   
   *Hybrid functional + ADMM + diagonalization + smearing:* I have not 
   tested this combination yet. However, I am concerned about whether it can 
   reliably preserve the physically meaningful spin-polarized electronic 
   distribution required for subsequent electronic-structure analysis. Such 
   calculations are particularly important because the purpose of performing 
   hybrid-functional calculations is often to obtain more reliable electronic 
   structures.
   
Therefore, I sincerely hope the development team will give this issue 
serious consideration. It would be extremely valuable to improve the 
robustness of SCF convergence for open-shell doublet systems with spin 
polarization, especially for semiconductor surface models with small band 
gaps. Ideally, users should be able to obtain reliable spin-polarized 
solutions without having to rely on smearing as the only viable approach, 
while retaining compatibility with subsequent hybrid-functional 
calculations.

Thank you very much for your time and for your continued development of 
CP2K.

Best regards,

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "cp2k" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to cp2k+unsubscribe at googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/cp2k/3620d4c3-3233-4d8b-ab2f-6b7113095df9n%40googlegroups.com.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.cp2k.org/archives/cp2k-user/attachments/20261104/c07e69b7/attachment.htm>


More information about the CP2K-user mailing list